Selvom at mange vendte sig direkte mod Warner Bros-ledelsen, da de lukkede ned for Batgirl-produktionen cirka seks måneder før den egentlige premiere, så er der sidenhen opstået lidt delte meninger blandt dem der nåede at se den.
Eksempelvis sagde en af de nye DCU-ledere, Peter Safran, at filmen simpelthen ikke var god nok til at udkomme, men stjernen bag filmen, Leslie Grace, er uenig. I et interview med Variety siger hun, at den film hun nåede at se, der blev screenet for produktionen inden det hele blev lukket ned, var "incredible":
"I got to see the film as far as it got to; the film wasn't complete by the time that it was tested. There were a bunch of scenes that weren't even in there. They were at the beginning of the editing process, and they were cut off because of everything going on at the company. But the film that I got to see — the scenes that were there — was incredible. There was definitely potential for a good film, in my opinion. Maybe we'll get to see clips of it later on."
Alt tyder på at filmen virkelig aldrig ser dagens lys, og Grace har bekræftet at hun ikke har snakket med hverken James Gunn eller Peter Safran.