Until Dawn har været en succes for PlayStation, og spillet holdte da også en syvende plads på de amerikanske salgslister igennem hele august, og en andenplads i England. I et nyt interview med PlayStation Lifestyle fortæller Executive Producer Pete Samuels om spillets salg:
"It's definitely surpassed expectations. I think that's already been stated in other interviews, and reports of significant retail outlets running out of stock during the first weeks after release kind of supports that."
Derudover taler Samuels lidt om potentialet for en efterfølger, og hvordan de kan arbejde rundt om en efterfølger på den traditionelle vis. Det lader til, at udvikleren allerede har diskussioner om dette internt:
"We do talk internally about what Until Dawn 2 could be, as it clearly can't be a sequel in the traditional sense, with the same characters facing the same threat, not least of which because in different stories some or all of them are already dead! We've investigated other ways we could do Until Dawn 2 but it probably is a little early to be discussing that."
